I am in rather a dilemma.
*I have a shameful secret to confess...
I actually read, and more extraordinarily agreed with, an column by
Miranda Devine.
I know, I know... I'm so ashamed. I'm worried that this may be a consequence of 'getting older'. It is an unsettling feeling that perhaps I am slowly morphing into Mary Whitehouse or Gerard Henderson or other fearsome conservative muppet. Could this be why I can't handle Dom Knight's pathetic 'blog posts' anymore? Is it bracket creep? Oh, the angst...
The
column decries the slipping of standards in film classifications, allowing 'moderate swearing' and 'implied sexual scenes' in PG and M movies. Although she was
hysterical about the blatant pedophilia and homoeroticism apparently depicted in 'The History Boys' recently, this time she was more rational and cited more evidence that indeed, it's not my imagination, they are allowing more previously unacceptable words, scenes, themes etc through the classification process.
...We are witnessing the acceleration of "ratings creep", the steady erosion of film classification standards, as more and more adult content seeps down into PG and M ratings, leaving parents powerless and confused about what to allow their children to watch.
Even G ratings are not what they used to be. A 2003 revision of movie classification guidelines allowed drug use and nudity "in context". Mild coarse language has always been allowed, as has "mild and very discreetly implied" sexual activity and drug use...
...The Sydney film reviewer Kevin Sadlier is one of the few who openly rails against the trend, on radio 2GB. He says he has noticed a "disturbing change" over the past 18 months in the work of the federal Office of Film and Literature Classification, which is responsible for movie ratings.
Movies that once would have been rated M, he says, are being released as PG - Marie Antoinette, with a nude love scene, for example.
The F-word, once restricted to MA movies, is now commonplace in M movies with a note from the censor warning of "moderate language"...
I agree with pretty much all of this - since when is 'mild drug use' ever going appropriate in a G rated movie? Although I guess it depends on the 'drug' in question...
However I disagree with this comment:
Ratings creep also applies to television, where the F-word is so liberally sprinkled through prime time it has lost its ability to shock, which is a pity. A program such as Supernatural shows graphic scenes of werewolves ripping people's hearts out of their chests.
Firstly: Pah! Supernatural SO does not show that much graphic violence. You saw the werewolf attack. And then you saw a chest cavity that had been shredded. You didn't see the shredding! Geez! Get it right Miranda!
Secondly: I'm not sure that the argument necessarily extends to TV. It is much easier to exercise parental control in regards to the TV - much easier to switch off and switch channels - than it is to up and leave a cinema. Also - I don't allow my children to watch prime-time TV, unless I'm absolutely positive that it'll be OK, and I would NEVER allow them to watch Supernatural, so that is such a pathetic straw man argument, and makes it easier for me to continue my Miranda H8ing**.
I guess my response is that surely it's easier to err on the side of caution in regards to film classification. I don't understand how 'society' could have changed so drastically in the last generation, that these aspects need to be reflected in G and PG movies. It's so hard to exercise the much-vaunted 'parental control' when the goal-posts keep moving! I'm not the type of parent who rants and raves about the rubbish on TV, and the possibility that my children might be exposed to sex and violence at 11pm, as it's my responsibility to ensure that they're not watching TV then... However I'm quite happy to rant if they're exposed to what I consider 'unsuitable' material if it's being broadcast through a medium I would normally considered 'safe' - eg G movies.
I'm lucky though, that I have a relationship with my children in which they are welcome to, and feel comfortable, discussing things they have seen or heard which left them puzzled, intrigued or uncomfortable. And for a parent that's more important than any film classification system.
* I would really appreciate discussion on this topic! People don't seem to 'discuss' things anymore - they either leave a comment saying 'yes I agree' or nothing. I would love C&C to be a place where we're happy to exchange ideas, and disagree with each other, yet still bask in the BlogLove!
** Stay tuned for more H8ing in the not-too-distant future!
Labels: Cranky (again), Curly Girls